Calendar

Immovable lifecycle review calendar

Blue dots are upcoming. Completed reviews turn green for correct thesis, red for wrong thesis, and orange when timing was off.

0

0 post-mortem tasks pending in tasks/pending/

This Month

9

0 upcoming, 9 historical review dates.

Completed

9

Review dates with post-mortems already ingested.

Month View

May 2026

Selected Date

4 May 2026

State Bank of India

SBIN • REVIEW_COMPLETE • earnings play

Hold 14 days • Review / exit 4 May 2026

-3.24% Post-mortem done
Thesis

SBI enters Q4 FY26 print season with sell-side PAT estimates clustering around Rs 18,500-19,500 cr and credit-cost moderation. Strong DII accumulation, benign funding costs from RBI VRR operations, and a benchmark deposit franchise leave downside risk asymmetric. Banking leadership into ICICI's April 26 print typically drags SBI higher ahead of its own Q4 date.

Prices

Entry: ₹1,107.90

Current: ₹1,071.95

P&L: -3.24%

Hold Plan

Target hold: 14 days

Held so far: 17 days

Review / exit: 4 May 2026

Review complete

Assumptions

A1: ICICI Bank Q4 print on April 26 delivers in line or ahead of consensus, sustaining banking leadership

A2: SBI Q4 FY26 results date falls within the May 9-May 15 window based on historical pattern

Lifecycle Timeline
Bought 20 Apr 2026

Accepted from analysis task analysis-2026-04-20-0830

Confirmed and held 21 Apr 2026

Thesis intact: ICICI's beat sets a strong bar, Q4 print scheduled for May 15 and ex-dividend May 18. Current ₹1,104 vs entry ₹1,107.9 is a 0.35% drawdown — well inside earnings-play tolerance. Banking sector rotation supportive.

Flagged for a closer look 30 Apr 2026

SBI remains close to entry, but banking has been less convincing than the headline index and provisioning concerns remain a sector overhang. Keep on WATCH until earnings timing and credit-cost commentary become clearer.

Reviewed and closed 7 May 2026

Post-mortem postmortem-REC-20260420-07-SBIN-2026-05-04 completed on 2026-05-07T16:09:20Z.

Post-Mortem

wrong

Exit n a
Review Return

Review price: ₹1,068.40

Full hold: -3.57%

Actual: -3.24%

Benchmarks

NIFTY 50: -1.01%

Excess: -2.56%

Sector excess: -0.55%

What If

Held full: -3.57%

Exited at WATCH: -1.78%

Thesis Analysis

SBI fell into review, underperformed NIFTY 50, and only roughly matched weak banking tape. ICICI's result did not sustain leadership, while SBI's own earnings catalyst remained ahead.

Exit Analysis

No formal exit was recorded. The WATCH move reduced risk awareness but did not crystallize an exit before the review-window underperformance.

Verified Assumptions
A1 Failed

ICICI Bank reported Q4 FY26 on April 18 with PAT up 8.5% YoY and lower provisions, but the assumed April 26 catalyst timing was wrong and Bank Nifty fell over the hold window.

A2 Failed

SBI scheduled its Q4 FY26/FY26 board meeting for May 8, 2026, earlier than the stated May 9-May 15 assumption window.

Lessons
high verify_peer_event_date_before_earnings_play

Earnings plays should not use stale peer-event dates as catalysts; verify announced calendars before accepting a hold window.

moderate require_explicit_target_and_stop

Large-cap bank earnings plays need an explicit target and stop when the primary event is still beyond the review date.

Corporate Events
earnings 15 May 2026

upcoming

ex dividend 18 May 2026

upcoming