This Month
5
0 upcoming, 5 historical review dates.
Calendar
Immovable lifecycle review calendar
0
0 post-mortem tasks pending in tasks/pending/
Completed
5
Review dates with post-mortems already ingested.
Selected Date
7 Jul 2026
Tata Consumer Products
TATACONSUM • REVIEW_COMPLETE • value fundamental
Hold 48 days • Review / exit 7 Jul 2026
-5.60% Post-mortem done
Tata Consumer Products
TATACONSUM • REVIEW_COMPLETE • value fundamental
Hold 48 days • Review / exit 7 Jul 2026
Tata Consumer has a fresh Q4 FY26 catalyst with revenue up about 18% YoY and FY26 revenue crossing Rs 20,000 crore. The stock is above its 50-DMA and 200-DMA with RSI below the hard overbought gate, giving a cleaner setup than most current result names.
Prices
Entry: ₹1,211.00
Current: ₹1,143.20
P&L: -5.60%
Hold Plan
Target hold: 48 days
Held so far: 15 days
Review / exit: 7 Jul 2026
Review complete
Assumptions
A1: The post-results breakout remains valid while price holds above the 200-DMA and does not close below the stop zone.
A2: FMCG rotation remains defensive-positive if crude, rupee and index volatility persist.
Bought 20 May 2026
Accepted from analysis task analysis-2026-05-20-0830
Confirmed and held 21 May 2026
TATACONSUM closed near Rs 1,208.70 versus Rs 1,211 entry and still holds above its 200-DMA, so the Q4 value-fundamental thesis remains intact.
Flagged for a closer look 22 May 2026
Auto-WATCH: ex_dividend event on 2026-05-25 is 3 days away
Sold 4 Jun 2026
At Rs 1,144 the stock is only slightly above its 6% stop from Rs 1,211, with RSI below 25 and bearish MACD.
Reviewed and closed 14 Aug 2026
Post-mortem postmortem-REC-20260520-02-TATACONSUM-2026-07-07 completed on 2026-08-14T05:00:00Z.
Post-Mortem
Exit correctwrong
Review Return
Review price: ₹1,125.00
Full hold: -7.10%
Actual: -5.60%
Benchmarks
NIFTY 50: +3.13%
Excess: -8.73%
Sector excess: -5.16%
What If
Held full: -7.10%
Exited at WATCH: -1.30%
Thesis Analysis
Q4 fundamentals held up (revenue +17.9% YoY, margin expansion; Citi retained Buy at Rs 1,450), but the technical premise failed: price broke below the 200-DMA within two weeks, stopped out at -5.6% on 4 Jun and closed Rs 1,125 at review (-7.1%) while NIFTY rose 3.1% and FMCG fell 0.4%.
Exit Analysis
Exit at Rs 1,143.2 (-5.6%) on 4 Jun, just above the 6% stop, avoided a further decline: the stock closed Rs 1,125 at review (-7.1%) and never traded back above entry. Holding to review would have lost roughly 1.5pp more.
Verified Assumptions
A1 Failed
Post-results breakout invalidated: price closed below the 200-DMA with RSI below 25 and bearish MACD, stopped out at Rs 1,143.2 on 4 Jun as it entered the 6% stop zone; never recovered.
A2 Failed
No defensive FMCG rotation despite crude and index volatility persisting: Nifty FMCG fell 0.44% over the window versus NIFTY +3.13%, and TATACONSUM was among the FMCG laggards.
Lessons
moderate value_fundamental_sector_relative_strength_gate
A value_fundamental entry with intact fundamentals can still fail badly when sector relative strength is absent: TATACONSUM's Q4 story stayed bullish (Citi Buy, Rs 1,450 target) yet the stock underperformed NIFTY by ~10pp and the FMCG index by ~7pp over the hold window; require a sector-relative-strength gate before post-results value entries in weak sectors.
high stop_loss_enforcement
Honoring the 6% stop when momentum turns (RSI below 25, bearish MACD) proved correct for value_fundamental picks: exiting at -5.6% avoided the further ~1.5pp drawdown to -7.1% at review, and the stock never reclaimed its entry price.
ex dividend 25 May 2026
upcoming
agm 10 Jun 2026
upcoming